Leiden Indo-European Etymological Dictionary Series, Dictionaries, Encyclopedias & Bibliographies, Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Germanic, Etymological Dictionary of the Iranian Verb. [6] In 2002 a paper by Ringe, Warnow and Taylor, employing computational methods as a supplement to the traditional linguistic subgrouping methodology, argued in favour of an Italo-Celtic subgroup,[7] and in 2007 Kortlandt attempted a reconstruction of a Proto-Italo-Celtic. Ojibwe Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic (Leiden; The Teacher's Grammar of English: A Course Book; Rethinking the Administrative Presidency: Trust, Otto Treumann: Graphic Design in the Netherlands; SOON Timepiece Phenomena: adventures in concept; Cartoon Modern: Style and Design in Fifties; Filmstile book; Neuropsychology: From Theory to Practice / As such, the term (s) in this entry are not directly attested, but are hypothesized to have existed based on comparative evidence. DenYeniseian Celtic languages share common features with Italic languages that are not found in other branches of Indo-European, suggesting the possibility of an earlier Italo-Celtic linguistic unity. (AncientGreek) Icelandic Interlingua Jizhao- It must be a more recent incomer. [8], Emphatic support for an Italo-Celtic clade came from Celtologist Peter Schrijver in 1991. Pama-Nyungan That is hardly even a cousin, it is practically a sister! Proto-Celtic The terms P-Celtic and Q-Celtic are useful for grouping Celtic languages based on the way they handle this one phoneme. The Old Irish a- and s-future come from here.[21]. Aromanian [5] Nevertheless, some scholars, such as Frederik Kortlandt, continued to be interested in the theory.
Galician Etymology. In: This page was last edited on 7 January 2023, at 18:40. NigerCongo A friend asked me to look into the origins of the saying An acorn doesn't fall far from the tree. (Cal)- Zazaki Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). Proto-Germanic Chechen
Proto-Celtic language - Wikipedia The s-, t-, and root aorist preterites take Indo-European secondary endings, while the reduplicated suffix preterite took stative endings. It was a descendant of the subjunctive of an Indo-European sigmatic thematic formation *-seti. Nepali In this paper, we defend the thesis that the set of absolute, There are around sixty Indo-European roots that are (sometimes) reconstructed with a vowel *a in the scholarly literature that otherwise fully embraces the laryngeal theory. Punjabi "colui che crea lodi"), la cui radice PIE *gerH- (originariamente "alzare la voce", poi "approvare, magnificare") riscontrabile anche nel latino grtus (e Tibeto-Burman (Nepal)) HaitianCreole I can only find a few examples of this saying online, but lots of examples of the apple never falls far from the tree and similar sayings.
Matasovic R. Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic As someone who has studied Classical Latin for years, Proto-Italic is fascinating to me. Muskogean LowerSorbian
Celtic cognates - Animals - Omniglot Falling Apples. Updates? Min Dong), This page was last edited on 10 May 2021, at 23:31. 1500 entries. ashes *loutwi-ask (*ged-) ask (*erk-, rek-) ask *l-je/o-ask *beg-e/o-, *bex-ske/o- (??) Slovak The following consonants have been reconstructed for Proto-Celtic (PC): PC stops allophonically manifest similarly to those in English. Frisian The Leiden University has compiled etymological dictionaries of various IE languages, a project supervised by Alexander Lubotsky and which includes a Proto-Celtic dictionary by Ranko Matasovi. ScottishGaelic
Dravidian Kuki-Chin "Ranko Matasovis Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic (henceforth EDPC), is a welcome and very useful tool for linguistic investigationwe are extremely grateful to Ranko Matasovi for his remarkable achievement." Epenthetic *i is inserted after syllabic liquids when followed by a plosive: Epenthetic *a is inserted before the remaining syllabic resonants: All remaining nonsyllabic laryngeals are lost. Long vowels are shortened before a syllable-final resonant (V:RC > VRC); this also shortens long diphthongs. Most verbs took one subjunctive suffix in Proto-Celtic, -(a)s-, followed by the thematic primary endings. Okinawan Answer (1 of 3): How can I learn the Proto Celtic language? This category has the following 13 subcategories, out of 13 total. Northern Kurdish South American 188K subscribers Like 57K views 2 years ago This video was made for educational purposes only. Dictionary Meanings Proto-celtic Definition Proto-celtic Definition Meanings Definition Source Pronoun Filter pronoun The putative ancestor of all the known Celtic languages. Semantic Scholar is a free, AI-powered research tool for scientific literature, based at the Allen Institute for AI. Wiktionary Advertisement Find Similar Words Find similar words to proto-celtic using the buttons below. On thematic -e/o- verbs, the imperative ended in thematic vowel *-e. However, there is also another second-person singular active imperative ending, -si, which was attached to the verb root athematically even with thematic strong verbs. Celtic words for fence, hurdle, lattice and related things come from the same root: more details, as do words for left and related things. Tibeto-Burman, 1.0 1.1 Matasovi, Ranko (2009), "*wasto-", in Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic (Leiden Indo-European Etymological Dictionary Series; 9), Leiden: Brill, ISBN, page 404 ^ Pokorny, Julius (1959) Indogermanisches etymologisches Wrterbuch [Indo-European Etymological Dictionary] (in German), volume 3, Bern . Sicilian) In Gaulish and the Brittonic languages, the Proto-Indo-European *k phoneme becomes a new *p sound.
Etymological Dictionary of Proto-celtic: 9 (Leiden Indo - Amazon American linguist Morris Swadesh believed that languages changed at measurable rates and that these could be determined even for languages without written precursors. Bikol Central Marathi On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Czech Finnic Contents 1 Proto-Celtic 1.1 Etymology 1.2 Noun 1.2.1 Declension 1.2.2 Descendants 1.3 References Proto-Celtic [ edit] Etymology [ edit]
Proto- Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster Middle) This is the first etymological dictionary of Proto-Celtic to be published after a hundred years, synthesizing the work of several generations of Celtic scholars. Penutian
Primitive Irish - Wikipedia A number of other similarities continue to be pointed out and debated.[13]. gcse.async = true; It contains a reconstructed lexicon, The discussion focuses on the problem of pre-Celtic substratum languages in the British Islands.
Latvian This page was last edited on 16 January 2023, at 05:09. Etymological Dictionary Of Proto Celtic : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive Etymological Dictionary Of Proto Celtic Publication date 2017-07-14 Topics linguistics, historical linguistics, indo-european languages, celtic languages Collection opensource Language English Welsh Hmong The stem vowel in the t-preterite was leveled to *e if the next consonant was either velar or *m, and *i in front of *r or *l.[20], One major formation of the future in Celtic, the s-future. Hindi Fongbe Tatar To be able to compare languages from different cultures, he based his lists on meanings he presumed would be available in as many cultures as possible. (, Plosives become *x before a different plosive or *s (CC > xC, Cs > xs), The reduplicated suffixless preterite (originating from the PIE reduplicated stative), This page was last edited on 4 March 2023, at 23:21. Walloon Tagalog Ivi, Dubravka. Celtic Dictionary. Proto-Celtic, or Common Celtic, is the ancestral proto-language of all known Celtic languages, and a descendant of Proto-Indo-European.It is not attested in writing but has been partly reconstructed through the comparative method.Proto-Celtic is generally thought to have been spoken between 1300 and 800 BC, after which it began to split into different languages. You can email a link to this page to a colleague or librarian: The link was not copied. Another future formation, attested only in Gaulish, is the -sye-desiderative. The phonological changes from Proto-Indo-European (PIE) to Proto-Celtic (PC) may be summarized as follows. Two of these verbs are *bwiyeti "to be, exist" (subjunctive *bweti) and *klinutor "to hear" (subjunctive *klowetor).[22]. LowSaxon This page was last edited on 3 July 2022, at 11:41. The genders were masculine, feminine and neuter; the numbers were singular, plural and dual. Suzhounese), Hakka,
Category:Proto-Celtic language - Wiktionary Celtic Hypothetical grouping of the Italic and Celtic language families, Michael Weiss, Italo-Celtica: Linguistic and Cultural Points of Contact between Italic and Celtic in, "Revisiting the classification of Gallo-Italic: a dialectometric approach", "NUEVA INSCRIPCIN LUSITANA PROCEDENTE DE PORTALEGRE", "Indo-European and Computational Cladistics", Italo-Celtic Origins and Prehistoric Development of the Irish Language, "17. The -the in Old Irish is secondary.
(Similarly, Grimm's law did not apply to *p, t, k after *s in Germanic, and the same exception occurred again in the High German consonant shift.). EMPIRES OF THE ATLANTIC WORLD EMPIRES OF THE ATLANTIC WORLD Britain and Spain in America 1492-1830 J. H. Elliott Yale University Press New Haven and London (OldPortuguese) Assamese While investigating Continental Celtic word-formation, I have come across some isoglosses which allow a less complicated reconstruction and, last not least, a better comprehension of the, Abstract The changes occurring in the Celtic word-field designating offspring are scrutinized and arranged into a somewhat revised relative chronology. We unlock the potential of millions of people worldwide. Guaran Sranan Lithuanian Standard, The study shows, among other things, how the, This paper presents a detailed etymological analysis of words for fox in Indo-European (IE) languages. (OldPersian, MiddlePersian) 1 March 2023. rather unambiguous despite appeals to archaic retentions or morphological leveling. [6] The changes are roughly in chronological order, with changes that operate on the outcome of earlier ones appearing later in the list. *e before a resonant and *a (but not *) becomes *a as well (eRa > aRa): *elH-ro > *gelaro > *galaro / *grH-no > *gerano > *garano (Joseph's rule). AntilleanCreole Musi Cantonese,
New genetic map reveals Irish people share far more DNA with the Buginese
Paleosiberian
Irish Wiktionary data extraction errors and warnings 1200900 BC. Wyandot Proto-Indo-Iranian In: Schmidt, Karl Horst, Contributions from New Data to the Reconstruction of the Proto-Language. (Mandarin Definition from Wiktionary, the free dictionary, Category:Requests concerning Proto-Celtic, Given names from Proto-Celtic by language, https://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?title=Category:Proto-Celtic_language&oldid=70848475, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Danish 1500 entries. SiberianTatar Indo-Iranian The Celtic Lexicon will contain the reconstructed Proto-Celtic vocabulary and the attested cognates in the ancient and modern Celtic languages (i.e. Irish gcse.src = 'https://cse.google.com/cse.js?cx=' + cx; Georgian Each lemma contains the reflexes of the Proto-Celtic words in the individual Celtic languages, the Proto-Indo-European (PIE) roots from which they developed, as well as the cognate forms from other Indo-European languages. Gaul. Cornish Dictionary. Jeju TokPisin Though Continental Celtic presents much substantiation for Proto-Celtic phonology, and some for its morphology, recorded material is too scanty to allow a secure reconstruction of syntax, though some complete sentences are recorded in the Continental Gaulish and Celtiberian. *mori 'body of water, sea' (neuter) (Gaulish Mori- ~ Old Irish muir ~ Welsh mr), E.g. Garo Proto-Hellenic American linguist Morris Swadesh believed that languages changed at measurable rates and that these could be determined even for languages without written precursors.
Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic - Google Books Sundanese Proto-Celtic is believed to have had nouns in three genders, three numbers and five to eight cases. Javanese
Reconstruction:Proto-Celtic/mrogis - Wiktionary [dubious discuss], The copula *esti was irregular. Uto-Aztecan, Esperanto Ancillary study: Sound Change, the Italo-Celtic Linguistic Unity, and the Italian Homeland of Celtic", "Early Celtic among the Indo-European dialects", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Italo-Celtic&oldid=1132194659, Short description is different from Wikidata, Articles containing Sanskrit-language text, Articles containing Ancient Greek (to 1453)-language text, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. the assimilation of *p to a following *k. Brittonic. Chinese Hungarian
au-3 (aue); u- - proto_roots.en-academic.com Konkani Afrikaans The number of cases is a subject of contention:[12] while Old Irish may have only five, the evidence from Continental Celtic is considered[by whom?] *slis 'sight, view, eye' (feminine) (Brittonic sulis ~ Old Irish sil), E.g. Thus, H can disappear in weak cases while being retained in strong cases, e.g. [citation needed] It can be inferred from Gaulish and Celtiberian as well as Insular Celtic that the Proto-Celtic verb had at least three moods: A probable optative mood also features in Gaulish (tixsintor) and an infinitive (with a characteristic ending -unei) in Celtiberian.[17][18]. Maltese Proto-Indo-European (PIE) voiced aspirate stops *b, *d, *g/, merge with *b, *d, *g/ in PC. Navajo They are usually considered to be innovations, likely to have developed after the breakup of the Proto-Indo-European language. Nynorsk) Yiddish Manx The. Khmer There are *o-stems, *-stems, *i-stems, *u-stems, dental stems, velar stems, nasal stems, *r-stems and *s-stems. Austronesian Finnish
John H Elliott - Empires Of The Atlantic World.pdf Reconstruction:Proto-Celtic/sukkos - Wiktionary How to use proto- in a sentence. Volapk, Proto-Austronesian This number is, 0.
Insofar as this new /p/ fills the gap in the phoneme inventory which was left by the disappearance of the equivalent stop in PIE, we may think of this as a chain shift. Maranao IE nom.sg. This is the first etymological dictionary of Proto-Celtic to be published after a hundred years, synthesizing the work of several generations of Celtic scholars. It contains a reconstructed lexicon of Proto-Celtic with ca. The assumed period of language contact could then be later and perhaps continue well into the first millennium BC. Hiligaynon There were two or three major preterite formations in Proto-Celtic, plus another moribund type.
Appendix:Proto-Celtic Swadesh list - Wiktionary This is the first etymological dictionary of Proto-Celtic to be published after a hundred years, synthesizing the work of several generations of Celtic scholars. Malayalam Whereas Continental Celtic offers plenty of evidence for phonology (the sound system), its records are too scanty to help. Bulgarian (Neapolitan, Sequences of velar and *w merge into the labiovelars (it is uncertain if this preceded or followed the next change; that is, whether gw > b or gw > g, but Schumacher 2004 argues on p.372 that this change came first; moreover, it is also found in Proto-Italic, and thus arguably belongs to the previous section): Aspirated stops lose their aspiration and merge with the voiced stops (except that this. Amharic Somali English Frisian Proto-Celtic, or Common Celtic, is the ancestral proto-language of all known Celtic languages, and a descendant of Proto-Indo-European. Il termine, trovato al plurale anche nel greco brdoi, sicuramente pi antico e proviene dal proto-celtico *bardos, a sua volta esito del proto-indoeuropeo *grdh--s ( lett.
PDF English - ProtoCeltic WordList - University of Wales Occitan Quechua Dalmatian From Proto-Indo-European *mor- (frontier, border). Portuguese Cypriot,
Etymological dictionary of proto-Celtic | WorldCat.org Chavacano Elamite Russian [2][3] Matasovi, however, is confused at how the -o- in *uo- became -a- in Gaulish and Brythonic. Using vocabulary lists, he sought to understand not only change over time but also the relationships of extant languages. Hebrew Novial The principal lemmata are alphabetically arranged words reconstructed for Proto-Celtic. English-Cornish Online Dictionary. However, Schumacher[4] and Schrijver[5] suggest a date for Proto-Celtic as early as the 13th century BC, the time of the Canegrate culture, in northwest Italy, and the Urnfield culture in Central Europe, implying that the divergence may have already started in the Bronze Age.[why?]. Many types of trees found in the Celtic nations are considered to be sacred, whether as symbols, or due to medicinal properties, or because they are seen as the abode of particular nature spirits.Historically and in folklore, the respect given to trees varies in different parts of the Celtic world. Gelao *m is assimilated or lost before a glide: *p assimilates to *k when another *k follows later in the word (pk > kk). Either derivation requires Narten ablaut anyway, leading to a stem vowel i in the singular and e in the plural. This is a Swadesh list of words in Proto-Celtic, compared with definitions in English. The focus is on the development of forms from PIE to Proto-Celtic, but histories of individual words are explained in detail, and each lemma is accompanied by an extensive bibliography. Capture a web page as it appears now for use as a trusted citation in the future. on July 14, 2017, This is a cleaned version of the original file found on The Internet, There are no reviews yet. That hypothesis fell out of favour after it was re-examined by Calvert Watkins in 1966. Proto-Celtic is generally thought to have been spoken between 1300 and 800 BC, after which it began to split into different languages. WestCoastBajau Egyptian Etruscan German Search the history of over 797 billion Gujarati
Addenda et Corrigenda to "Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic original Indo-European language features which have disappeared in all other language groups. It contains a reconstructed. E.g. Makasar This is the first etymological dictionary of Proto-Celtic to be published after a hundred years, synthesizing the work of several generations of Celtic scholars. W Belyn. This page was last edited on 4 March 2023, at 06:08. It contains a reconstructed lexicon of Proto-Celtic with ca. Moroccan, Betawi Thus, PIE *gen- 'woman' became Old Irish and Old Welsh ben, but PIE *gn- 'to kill, wound' became Old Irish gonaid and Welsh gwanu. Sanskrit The r-passive (mediopassive voice) was initially thought to be an innovation restricted to Italo-Celtic until it was found to be a retained archaism shared with Hittite, Tocharian, and possibly the Phrygian language. Proto-Basque Estonian The primary endings in Proto-Celtic were as follows. The list of the Proto-Celtic sound laws is explicitly adduced in the Introduction to the dictionary, and all etymologies in this dictionary are based on the assumption that those sound laws operated in Proto-Celtic. These changes are shared by several other Indo-European branches. *dug, Indogermanisches etymologisches Wrterbuch, "The Origin of the Welsh Englyn and Kindred Metres", Celto-Germanic Later Prehistory and Post-Proto-Indo-European vocabulary in the North and West, "17. Schrijver supposes that its athematic present was used clause-initially and the thematic conjugation was used when that was not the case.[28]. The collective memory of the Proto-Israelites suffering in Canaan under Egyptian oppression and those suffering in Egypt merged in the genesis of Israel's story of origin from the transformation of oral tradition into written text. Derived from Proto-Indo-European *upo-sth--s (standing beneath), from *up (under) + *steh- (to stand) + *-s (agent suffix). See More Copyright Year: 2009 Hardback Availability: Published ISBN: 978-90-04-17336-1 Publication date: The following sound changes are shared with the Italic languages in particular, and are cited in support of the Italo-Celtic hypothesis.[7]. Romani Imperative endings in Proto-Celtic were as follows:[14]:147148, The second-person singular imperative was generally endingless in the active; no ending was generally added to athematic verbs. Belenus. Words from the same Proto-Celtic root, via Gaulish and Latin, include claie (wicker rack, trellis, hurdle) in French and cheda (wattled laterals at the base of a traditional cart) in Galician [ source ]. Norwegian: A reformulated list was published posthumously in 1971.
The Sound of the Proto-Celtic language (Numbers, Words & Story) Nanjingnese), This question misunderstands the nature of protolanguages. Berber Burushaski Malagasy Gan, The German philologist Sabine Ziegler, however, drawing parallels with reconstructions of the Proto-Celtic language morphology (whose nouns are classified according to the vowels that characterize their endings), limited the archaic Irish endings of the singular genitive to -i, -as, -os and -ais . As such, the term (s) in this entry are not directly attested, but are hypothesized to have existed based on comparative evidence. It would then analogically spread to other Celtic strong verb roots ending in sonorants in addition to the weak verbs, even if the root did not originally end in a laryngeal. Hmong-Mien Those dictionaries published by Brill in the Leiden series have been removed from the University databases for copyright reasons. (OldPolish) Guinea-BissauCreole Patrizia de Bernardo Stempel. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. TocharianB Bengali Goidelic. Thai Please support me on. Serbo-Croatian Min Hausa Category:Proto-Celtic names: Proto-Celtic terms that are used to refer to specific individuals or groups. There is controversy about the causes of these similarities. Cape Verdean UpperSorbian Polish Tahitian Japanese Breton Kho-Bwa, Omissions? 1500 entries. These cases were nominative, vocative, accusative, dative, genitive, ablative, locative and instrumental. At the moment we have published the following online documents: 1500 entries. So many of the sound changes that occurred from Proto-Italic to Old Latin to Classical Latin are so interesting. Uploaded by Palestinian, It is also possible that some of these are not innovations, but shared conservative features, i.e. About us. The voiced aspirate labiovelar *g did not merge with *g, though: plain *g became PC *b, while aspirated *g became *g. [1] However, Schrijver believes that in Brythonic, sequences of *wo regularly split into *wa and *wo depending on whether the *w was lenited; in this case, the vowel in the Brythonic descendants would be generalized from the lenited form. Corrections? Please, contact us for this at ats [at] ats-group [dot] net, Advanced Translation Services| Copyright 2001-2023| ATS Translation, Professional Hungarian Translation Services. Proto-Celtic is often associated with the Urnfield culture and particularly with the Hallstatt culture. It is a descendant of the Proto-Indo-European (h)se-desirative, with i-reduplication in many verbs. Hawaiian Burmese
Proto-Celtic language | Britannica Formosan Purepecha Mongolian Thus, Gaulish petuar[ios], Welsh pedwar "four", but Old Irish cethair and Latin quattuor. Korean The considerable genetic legacies of the Vikings, Normans and Ulster plantations has uncovered a previously hidden genetic landscape, shaped by invasions and migrations. Berber: Greek Slovene (Sinitic,
PDF ProtoCeltic - English WordList - University of Wales Telugu
Numbers in Proto-Brythonic - Omniglot Etymological Dictionary Of Proto Celtic - Internet Archive Proto-Japanese Papiamento The article discusses a number of cases in which Proto-Indo-European word-initial sequences of the type *Hi- and *Hu- yield an acute vowel in Baltic and in Slavic.
Etymological Dictionary of Proto-Celtic (Leiden Numbers in Proto-Brythonic How to count in Proto-Brythonic, the reconstructed ancestor of the Brythonic branch of the Insular Celtic languages (Welsh, Cornish, Breton and Cumbric). Bashkir The Celtic languages are the languages descended from Proto-Celtic, or "Common Celtic", a branch of the greater Indo-European language family. It contains a reconstructed lexicon of Proto-Celtic with ca. Swahili
Early New) Latin Similar developments appear in Italic, but for the syllabic nasals *m, *n, the result is Proto-Italic *m, *n (> Latin em ~ im, en ~ in). It contains a reconstructed lexicon of Proto-Celtic with ca.
Proto-Celtic: meaning, synonyms - WordSense (Sallaands) Proto-Celtic is usually dated to the Late Bronze Age, ca. Central Atlas Tamazight) Kangean
Italo-Celtic - Wikipedia Vietnamese Sino-Tibetan: (OldMarathi) Subsequently, it was reduced to 207, and reduced much further to 100 meanings in 1955. on the Internet. PIE *sp- became Old Irish s (lenited f-, exactly as for PIE *sw-) and Brythonic f; while Schrijver 1995, p.348 argues there was an intermediate stage *s- (in which * remained an independent phoneme until after Proto-Insular Celtic had diverged into Goidelic and Brythonic), McCone 1996, pp. Etymological dictionary of proto-Celtic Author: Ranko Matasovi Summary: "This is the first etymological dictionary of Proto-Celtic to be published after a hundred years, synthesizing the work of several generations of Celtic scholars. They were used to form the present, future, and subjunctive conjugations.[14]. The stem might be thematic or athematic, an open or a closed syllable. Words with an asterisk are . Cornish [3] The fact that it is possible to reconstruct a Proto-Celtic word for 'iron' (traditionally reconstructed as *sarnom) has long been taken as an indication that the divergence into individual Celtic languages did not start until the Iron Age (8th century BCE to 1st century BCE); otherwise, descendant languages would have developed their own, unrelated words for their metal. (Old French) The later belief in a stay of the Israelites at Tanis/Zoan was inspired by the transfer of archaeological . English-Cornish Online Dictionary. A collection of Celtic cognates, with definitions, pronunciation, etymologies - includes the modern Celtic languages, older versions of these languages, such as Middle Welsh, Old Irish, and their extinct and reconstructed relatives and ancestors, including Gaulish, Celtiberian, Proto-Brythonic and Proto-Celtic. Mayan Proto-Indo-European Catalan The article by R. Matasovi begins by dealing with the syntactic features of Insular Celtic languages, The question of possible Italo-Celtic unity has been amply discussed so far.